This project is graded out of 100 points.
| 20 points | 15 points | 10 points | 5 points | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contributions | Makes many substantive contributions. Contributions clearly connected to discussion. | Makes at least 3 substantive contributions. Connections to discussion may be tangential. | Makes at least 1 substantive contribution. Speaker may not be able to connect to discussion. | No contributions are made. |
| Reasoning and Evidence | Uses strong evidence from text, with accurate citation. | Uses evidence to support some points, most with citation. | Uses minimal evidence or evidence is not cited. | No evidence is presented. |
| Participation | Encourages other participants. Does not interrupt or monopolize discussion. | Avoids disrupting others. Generally does not interrupt or monopolize discussion. | Disrupts other participants by interrupting frequently or monopolizing discussion. | Does not participate. |
| Delivery | Speaks clearly, concisely, understandably, and appropriately. | Occasionally difficult to hear or understand. | Difficult to hear and/or understand, and/or significantly inappropriate. | Does not speak. |
| Preparation | Annotated print copies of articles turned in and PDF copies of both articles uploaded to Moodle. | One annotated print copy not turned in or one PDF copy not uploaded. | No annotated copies turned in, no PDF copies uploaded, or only one article used. | None of these complete at beginning of discussion period. |